It's not about the shoes (NYCBR in the Times Magazine)

This is cool.  The upcoming Times Magazine features the New York City Barefoot Run in an article by Christopher McDougall.  The article is about people who wear minimalist running shoes, but still run with bad form -- and an old technique to get improve your form.

If everything comes together just right, you’ll be exactly where Larson was one Sunday morning in September: peeking out from behind a tree on Governors Island in New York Harbor, his digital video camera nearly invisible on an ankle-high tripod, as the Second Annual New York City Barefoot Run got under way about a quarter-mile up the road. Hundreds of runners — men and women, young and old, athletic and not so much so, natives from 11 different countries — came pattering down the asphalt straight toward his viewfinder.

Nice.

But the article makes an enormously important point: running in minimalist shoes doesn't guarantee good form.

“Barefoot-style” shoes are now a $1.7 billion industry. But simply putting something different on your feet doesn’t make you a gliding Tarahumara. The “one best way” isn’t about footwear. It’s about form. Learn to run gently, and you can wear anything. Fail to do so, and no shoe — or lack of shoe — will make a difference.

That’s what Peter Larson discovered when he reviewed his footage after the New York City Barefoot Run. “It amazed me how many people in FiveFingers were still landing on their heels,” he says. They wanted to land lightly on their forefeet, or they wouldn’t be in FiveFingers, but there was a disconnect between their intentions and their actual movements.

Take a look at these heel strikes at the NYCBR in minimalist shoes...and even barefoot.

This is one of the areas, incidentally, where Vibram has failed on a massive scale.  They've sold millions of pairs of FiveFingers, but they've done next to nothing to help those people run with proper form and avoid injury.  With every pair of VFFs sold, they should be providing basic instructions on barefoot running form.

We've got to re-wire our nervous system and get rid of the bad habits.  McDougall writes about an old training technique he re-discovered that helps people develop the proper form.

I was leafing through the back of an out-of-print book, a collection of runners’ biographies called “The Five Kings of Distance,” when I came across a three-page essay from 1908 titled “W. G. George’s Own Account From the 100-Up Exercise.” According to legend, this single drill turned a 16-year-old with almost no running experience into the foremost racer of his day.

For the actual technique, go read the full article.  And don't forget to attend the 3rd Annual New York City Barefoot Run next year.

Comments

Does the exercise really

Does the exercise really imply you should be running regularly lifting knees to hip height? What about the "gliding" of the Tarahumara, or of martial artists, where the foot "hovers" over the ground? Wouldn't lifting that high that be somewhat wasted motion? And besides, the higher you lift , the more gravity impacts, and I find that I hit the ground harder that way, even when I'm consciously landing softer. Maybe it's a great training method, but I'm not sure it works so well for me in real practice. And I use midfoot strike, not fully a ball of foot strike. Now, my running form is quite flawed, or at least not that pretty, expecially when I'm carrying a pack, but it does seem to work. -Ira

I don't get how you *CAN* run

I don't get how you *CAN* run like that in a minimalist shoe.  I used to be a seriously crappy runner (and I hated it) until I put on a pair of Vibrams, realized I had to land on the ball of my foot, realized simultaneously that my foot, ankle and calves were actually a big SPRING - and it alll worked, suddenly.  And running felt good and I liked it and now I run pretty frequently.  (I actually bought the Vibrams for hiking, not running.)Maybe it's people who ran for years in running shoes - they just got trained into wrongness?

I'm a huge fan of vibram

I'm a huge fan of vibram shoes; I'm on my 7th pair. But they are really a terrible value. They are priced like a comparable non-minimal shoe. But the soles wear out in a third the time. I know, it's a feature, not a bug, in software-speak, to have such a thin sole. But the least they could do is include a DVD of training videos for proper barefoot running. Or at least some good training videos on their website. I really feel like this idea of natural running is getting ready to go mainstream in a very big way, but we're also going to see a massive number of injuries if these shoes don't come with a better owner's manual. 

I just read this article,

I just read this article, it's wonderful! And timely. I plan to try the 100-up method, it gave me a real "Duh! Why didn't I think of that!" moment. It was really cool to see the NYCBR talked about in the article though - way to go! It was a great event and it looks to be a game changer in a lot of ways.

 For readers, barefoot or

 For readers, barefoot or not, who want to know more how better form can improve their running, this video form series will help you:  RUNNING